Advice From A Pro: What Every Hiring Manager Should Be Told

The time that good candidates are on the market is shorter than it’s ever been.

The number of good candidates that are on the market is fewer than it’s been in 10 years.

The money you paid two years ago or even one year ago won’t get the kind of candidate you really want.

Candidates are not as prone to fill out online applications as they used to be.

Candidates won’t talk to your 22-year-old corporate recruiter whose job it is to screen them.

Candidates are not going to go to your  tracking portal to apply for your job.

Talk to the Candidate

Candidates don’t want to talk to anyone but the hiring authority. Why? Because the other people who are trying to hire this candidate are having their managers talk with them directly. The candidate you like is being considered by at least three other organizations; he or she has many choices.

If you tell a candidate that you’re going to get back to them by a certain time, best do it. A few years ago good candidates had to put up with  being treated poorly. Not anymore. They have too many choices now. Your competition is courting them heavily.

A lowball offer is likely to be rejected.

Say Goodbye to Team Meetings

“We want you to meet the team just so you can get a feel for our company,” has a different translation for top talent. The REAL TRUTH is: “So they can possibly eliminate you as competition.” This request will be ignored or outright refused by candidates. The majority of the time they are employed and are getting so many “real” interviews, they don’t need or take the time for team meetings.

Candidates are more likely to receive counteroffers than they ever have in the past.

Candidates may not have an updated resume. In this market, they may not need one. Please don’t recite the mantra, “Well if they’re serious about looking for a job they’ll have a new resume.” Their “seriousness” simply depends on if the opportunity you have allows them to better themselves.

Assume that if you’re going to make a candidate an offer, so are two other organizations.

Candidates won’t tolerate the “nine person interviewing process that we have to have in order to be careful and be sure we hire the right person.” They don’t have to put up with this anymore. Your competition is interviewing them no more than three times and making them an offer —  and doing it quickly!

Article Continues Below

Candidates don’t have to consider “temp-to-perm” types of opportunities. There are so many companies willing to hire them permanently from the get-go. While you’re trying to be “careful” by hiring them “temp-to-perm,” your competitor is making a long term commitment, with benefits that start immediately.

Sell Your Job

Give candidates real good reasons why they ought to be going to work for you. The idea that “anyone would be lucky to work here” just doesn’t fly anymore.

Treat every candidate as though they were being ‘recruited’; happy with their job;with a number of suitors and choices.

Your interviewing cycle needs to be short. Anything beyond 10 working days is a risk. Your competition is moving faster than that.

Tell your HR recruiting department to respectfully get out of the way. Their protective compliance activities are costing you candidates. They really don’t think about how hard it is to find these folks, they don’t have quotas. No one in their department complains about having to do the work of two people while you are trying to fill a vacancy. They’re trying to protect their job by telling you they are helping you.

Also, talk to the candidate directly. If candidates have to go through your H.R./recruiter/admin./office manager/screener, etc., they don’t feel loved and will be more likely to go to work for hiring managers who establish a personal rapport with them.

Please stop saying to candidates that, “Hiring is one of the most important things I do…,” then act like hiring them is not a high priority by not returning their calls, keeping in touch with them, postponing a decision, keeping them in the dark, going silent, etc.

No Purple Squirrels

Stop looking for Mr. or Ms. Perfect — the purple squirrel who doesn’t really exist or, if they do, they are happily employed and making more money than you can afford. It will take you months to come to the conclusion that you’re not going to find this perfect person and you’d best try to hire the best athlete you can find — the person who has been a winner at most everything they’ve ever done but, just not in the exact area you are searching.  In the time it takes to find Mr. or Ms. Perfect, you can hire one of these best athletes and train them.

Try to avoid writing a wish list of requirements that reflect your fear of hiring the wrong person. We got one of these lists the other day and it had 32 items on it. The vice president who sent it to us laughed, saying that he’s not sure why he wrote all this stuff down and that even he didn’t have all of these requirements. He didn’t know of anyone who did.

Image: SOMMAI /

Since 1973, Tony Beshara has placed more than 7,000 people on a one-on-one basis, in more than 100 different job categories. His candidates have accepted positions earning minimum wage and salaries up to more than a million dollars a year. Tony has directly worked with more than 24,000 hiring authorities, at 21,000 different hiring organizations. The system he has developed has helped more than 100,000 people find jobs. Tony's first book, The Job Search Solution, was one of the top ten best sellers in 2005 in its category and its success led to the creation of, a web-based training program believed to be the first of its kind for people going through the job search process. His second book, Acing the Interview, was released in January 2008 and has received very positive reviews from critics. He is president of Babich and Associates.


3 Comments on “Advice From A Pro: What Every Hiring Manager Should Be Told

  1. I hear you, and I agree. Unfortunately no one will listen to this…

    You will be as successful getting employers to trim 32 bullet point wishlists for this ‘Purple Squirrel’ job candidate as you will be convincing aging women to stop making 32 point Prince Charming wishlists and choose decent men who would be willing to marry them.

    Furthermore, over-reliance on keyword-packed algorithms in ATS systems is scarily like the movie “Weird Science”, where two nerds create a perfect woman out of thin air with a computer program (they input their dream girl wishlist and presto- she appeared). You cannot derive real candidates from out of thin air. That is magical thinking, pure and simple. Sadly, this is exactly how hiring operates all too often.

    The Purple Squirrel and Prince Charming are both fictional, but they will persist in the human psyche.

    One would wish that hiring managers would network and recruit from pools of actual human beings and HR would go back to just being a personnel department, but that would be too realistic.

    Hiring is living in a fantasy world.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *