Job Growth Up; But How Real Are the Numbers?

What should we make of this morning’s National Employment Report?

It should be considered good news that the report estimates 187,000 private sector jobs were created in January. After all, the average of the various guesses by economists was 140,000, according to Bloomberg News, which does a monthly survey.

But within minutes of the release of the ADP sponsored report, stock futures dipped, and then, when the market opened in New York at 9:30, the Dow began to pull back from Tuesday’s high. Meanwhile, the Wall Street Journal published a blog post headlined “ADP Jobs Report Shows Hottish Job Market – But Is It Hot?

There are probably as many reasons for today’s stock market fluctuations as there are headlines, so it wouldn’t be fair, nor accurate, to suggest any significant linkage between today’s market action and the ADP report.

However, the ADP report is considered a harbinger of the government’s monthly employment report, which is typically released two days later. The monthly Employment Situation Summary covering December will be released in Washington on Friday.

From data compiled from surveys of employers and households across the country, the U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics reports job creation and loss in the preceding month. The report also contains a great deal more, including wage changes, the national unemployment rate, workweek hours, and the demographics of the labor force. Since the recession began, this report has often been a market mover.

As of this morning, economists, on average, are expecting that the government will report about 140,000 (MarketWatch and Bloomberg) (136,000 Dow Jones survey) jobs created in January. Some of the surveys predict the unemployment rate will rise to 9.5 percent from 9.4 percent.

However, as you consider these predictions, and the ADP bell cow report, bear in mind that the job estimates are averages of multiple predictions that can show a stunning range. For instance , in the Bloomberg survey of what economists expected the ADP report to show the guesses ranged from a loss of 100,000 jobs to a gain of 200,000; the 140,000 estimate was nothing more than an average of these guesses.

There’s also a great deal of  uncertainty about the predictive value of the ADP report.

As the Wall Street Journal post noted, quoting an economist with High Frequency Economics, “We are struggling to make sense of these numbers.”

Since the National Employment Report numbers are based on ADP’s payroll processing data — and ADP handles only private sector payrolls — the numbers don’t include government employment, which has been declining for months.

Article Continues Below

In addition, ADP’s 500,000 payrolls cover over 23 million employees. A big share of the American workforce to be sure, but even so, the numbers require statistical adjustment, which is done by ADP’s partner, Macroeconomic Advisers.

Rarely have the numbers tracked well with the Labor Department’s. Today’s ADP report included a 50,000 downward adjustment in the job count for November. ADP initially reported 297,000 jobs were created in November. The BLS report two days later put the official job increase at 103,000. That number, typically, will also be revised in Friday’s report.

Despite all these vagaries, it would be wrong to dismiss the job reports. For one, the trend is clearly up. The U.S. economy is creating jobs. How fast? Not fast enough to appreciably change the unemployment numbers. On that, everyone agrees.

Dig deeper into the reports and there’s a wealth of useful information about where the jobs are being created or lost; the industry sectors that are changing; and the geographies involved.

The ADP report notes: “Employment among large businesses, defined as those with 500 or more workers, increased by 11,000 while employment among medium-size businesses, defined as those with between 50 and 499 workers, increased by 79,000. Employment among small- size businesses, defined as those with fewer than 50 workers, increased by 97,000.”

Thursday, the Monster Employment Index will be released. It may not get the business press attention the ADP report does, but it offers recruiters even deeper and more valuable pointers about hiring. If you need help seeing how it can help, Monster’s Knowledge Officer provides advice.

John Zappe is the editor of and a contributing editor of John was a newspaper reporter and editor until his geek gene lead him to launch his first website in 1994. He developed and managed online newspaper employment sites and sold advertising services to recruiters and employers. Before joining ERE Media in 2006, John was a senior consultant and analyst with Advanced Interactive Media and previously was Vice President of Digital Media for the Los Angeles Newspaper Group.

Besides writing for ERE, John consults with staffing firms and employment agencies, providing content and managing their social media programs. He also works with organizations and businesses to assist with audience development and marketing. In his spare time  he can be found hiking in the California mountains or competing in canine agility and obedience competitions.

You can contact him here.


5 Comments on “Job Growth Up; But How Real Are the Numbers?

  1. IMHO, the Great Recession will end (from an unemployment perspective) when the unemployment rate dips below 7.0% for three consecutive months.


  2. The recession is alive and well and the government is doing a great job of keeping it that way. I don’t think for a 2nd we are coming out of this-more like swimming around in the sewer system.Sleepless in Seattle, clueless in Washington,DC.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *