Monthly Jobs Report Is a Mixed Bag; Just Like The Economy

Economic Indices Jan 2010This morning’s monthly jobs report was a mixed bag offering something for both the bears and the bulls.The good news: Unemployment dropped from 10 percent to 9.7 percent. The bad news: The economy continued to lose jobs, shedding 20,000 in January when economists expected jobs to at least be flat, if not grow.

The U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics also revised its reports for November and December. In November, the BLS now says the economy gained 64,000 jobs, up from its previous estimate of a 4,000 job gain.

That improvement was more than offset by the bureau’s revision to its December number. Instead of the 85,000 job loss it first reported, the BLS now says 150,000 jobs were actually lost.

The report prompted Morgan Stanley’s David Greenlaw to tell Marketwatch, “All in all, we see encouraging signs of progress in labor market conditions and expect to see much better payroll performance in coming months.”

Economists had been expecting a job gain in January, but also a slight worsening of the unemployment rate. A Reuters survey said the average of the economist predictions was for a gain of 5,000 jobs. Marketwatch’s survey put the job growth at 25,000.

The BLS report was complicated by adjustments the bureau made to its data and the introduction of expanded reports, including reports detailing the labor situation of veterans, individuals with disabilities, and the foreign born, and more depth in other areas.

The data revisions adjusted the size of the labor force back to January 2009, which meant that the monthly job changes as first reported were too low. The revisions added 617,000 more lost jobs to the 2009 totals, making the official count for the year a loss of 4.78 million jobs. And the December number is subject to still further revision.

Article Continues Below

The BLS also reported that the number of unemployed persons by reason of job loss decreased by 378,000 to 9.3 million. Nearly all of this decline occurred among permanent job losers (which, according to the BLS, means “persons whose employment ended involuntarily and who began looking for work”). However, the long-term unemployed (those jobless for 27 weeks and over) was up in January to 6.3 million. Since the start of the recession in December 2007, the number of long-term unemployed has risen by 5.0 million.

Other indices reflected essentially the same yin-yang as the BLS. The Monster Employment Index was down 1 point, while The Conference Board’s count of new, online jobs, showed a gain of 381,800 over December. That’s the biggest jump in new online postings since the Help Wanted OnLine Data Series began in May 2005. But the total number of jobs posted online is still lower than every month in 2008 except for December.

The Consumer Confidence Index also ticked upwards slightly, mostly due to consumers’ more positive outlook for the short term. (The Consumer Confidence Index is a composite of multiple indices derived from a monthly survey conducted by The Conference Board.)

Says Lynn Franco, director of The Conference Board Consumer Research Center, “Consumer Confidence rose for the third consecutive month, primarily the result of an improvement in present-day conditions. Consumers’ short-term outlook, while moderately more positive, does not suggest any significant pickup in activity in the coming months. Regarding their financial situation, while consumers were less dire about their income prospects than in December, the number of pessimists continues to outnumber the optimists.”

John Zappe is the editor of and a contributing editor of John was a newspaper reporter and editor until his geek gene lead him to launch his first website in 1994. He developed and managed online newspaper employment sites and sold advertising services to recruiters and employers. Before joining ERE Media in 2006, John was a senior consultant and analyst with Advanced Interactive Media and previously was Vice President of Digital Media for the Los Angeles Newspaper Group.

Besides writing for ERE, John consults with staffing firms and employment agencies, providing content and managing their social media programs. He also works with organizations and businesses to assist with audience development and marketing. In his spare time  he can be found hiking in the California mountains or competing in canine agility and obedience competitions.

You can contact him here.


6 Comments on “Monthly Jobs Report Is a Mixed Bag; Just Like The Economy

  1. As a job-seeking college senior, I can relate real well to this report. I’ve searched out jobs in my industry and jobs in other industries, but even if someone is hiring, it seems a jobless better suited candidate always comes along to steal the position. Job reports only report numbers and figures, but job seeking paints the real picture. I have mixed feelings about job hunting. I hear the occasional, “Companies are looking for young, new, vibrant candidates to take the position” but it seems to me, they are looking for someone better qualified. Of course anyone out in the job world for 20 years is going to have a better outlook and point of view on specifics when it comes to a company. I’m new and I bring new fresh ideas, so look at me!

  2. As a recent graduate experiencing the “real world” of job searching during a Recession, there is only one fact that I have stumbled across. There are no facts. The job reports tell us nothing. They are so littered with insignificant data it’s hard to pull any hope from them. The unemployment percentage means less when the number of “long-term unemployed” increases regularly. When 5 million people looking for work can’t find it, they are costing our government more in unemployment benefits, but the number of online job postings indicates there ARE jobs. Perhaps a generation is having trouble adapting to a technology driven world.

  3. Synopsis:
    Early reports from Feb. 5 showed a decline in unemployment from 10% to 9.7%. However, there was a loss of 20,000 jobs in January. U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics revised their November and December reports and shows a gain of 64,000 jobs, but 150,000 jobs were lost. Also, B.L.S. reports the total job loss of 2009 to be 4.78 million jobs. Unemployed persons due to, “…job loss decreased 378,000 to 9.3 million” (Zappe). Further reports by the B.L.S. show the number of persons unemployed over 26weeks has risen by 5.0 million. Various indices show similar see-saw reports. Monster employment index fell 1 point. While the Conference Board Count of, “… new, online jobs, showed a gain of 381,800 over December” (Zappe). In sum, the total number of jobs posted online has been lower than every month in 2008; save December.
    Despite the various reports, revisions of reports, and consumer outlooks on the job-market, I remain unemployed yet willing to work.

  4. It has been measured that the unemployment ratio has slightly got reduced. Economists are expecting a growth in the coming days but different surveys, job reports give different predictions so it anyway is mixed up. According to Conference Board’s statement of 381,800 jobs gained over December, reflects online job postings make a bridge for over heading the current situation.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *